A guessing game and associated playing method is provided. The guessing game (10) includes a plurality of game pieces such as marbles. A support structure (12) is provided which includes at least two indented receptacles (14) for selectively receiving the game pieces. These receptacles (14) define the playing positions of the players. Cover members (16) are operatively associated with each of the receptacles (14) and are secured proximate each of the receptacles such that a player can access the game pieces within his receptacle in a concealed fashion.